Which is better, Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny? That's the first elementary school theological argument that I can remember getting into.
(Both figures, of course, represent a kind of temporary children's autonomy. For both, you're up early, before anyone else, and in full control of the house; not only that, but you get rewarded for it.)
For most of the other kids, the answer to this question was a no-brainer, but I can remember—characteristically enough—holding out for the minority position.
Santa just brings you clothes and socks and stuff that you don't want anyway, went my argument.
(In rather poignant hindsight, I can rephrase this as: Santa brings you things that you would want if you were who they thought you were, or rather, if you were who they wanted you to be. Thus, Santa and his gifts paradoxically embody a kind of existential parental rejection.)
The Bunny, on the other hand, brings you bad stuff.
Really: what other day of the year do you get to gorge on candy before breakfast?
On top of which, he makes you work for it.
(In retrospect, I can see here also the stirrings of an early proto-pagan instinct: Santa : culture :: Easter Bunny : nature.)
Sorry, folks: more than 50 years on, I stick with my original position.
The Bunny is way better.
-
I drove past an egg tree in someone's front yard the other day: its exuberant colors against the dull early Spring Minnesota lands
-
Growing up I enjoyed them both with enthusiasm each in his own time. Nowadays the people who lived in the house before I moved in